Media Access Control in Streaming: Protocols Compared

This article compares 5 key streaming protocols: RTMP, HLS, MPEG-DASH, WebRTC, and SRT. Here’s a quick overview:

Protocol	Latency	Best For	Key Feature
RTMP	2-5 seconds	Live events, gaming	Low delay
HLS	6-30+ seconds	Wide device support	Adaptability
MPEG-DASH	6-30+ seconds	Adaptive streaming	Flexibility
WebRTC	<1 second	Real-time communication	Fastest speed
SRT	1-2 seconds	Poor network conditions	Error correction

The article covers:

• How Media Access Control works in streaming
• Detailed comparison of each protocol’s latency, scalability, security, compatibility, and quality of service
• Strengths and weaknesses of each method
• New developments in streaming technology
• How to choose the right protocol for your needs
• Future trends in streaming protocols

Key takeaways:

• No single protocol is best for all situations
• Consider your specific requirements for speed, audience size, video quality, and security when choosing
• Newer protocols like WebRTC and SRT are gaining traction for their low latency and network resilience

Related video from YouTube

What is Media Access Control?

Media Access Control (MAC) is a key part of how computers talk to each other in networks. It’s like a traffic cop for data, making sure information gets where it needs to go without crashing into other data.

Here’s what MAC does in streaming:

1. Checks if the network is free: Before sending data, MAC looks to see if anyone else is using the network.

2. Packages data: MAC puts streaming data into neat packages with important details like where it’s going and where it came from.

3. Fixes errors: If data gets messed up along the way, MAC can often spot and fix the problem.

4. Controls data flow: MAC makes sure devices don’t send too much data too fast, which could overwhelm the receiver.

Here’s how MAC works when you stream something:

Step	What Happens
1. Request	Your device asks for the video or music
2. Check Network	MAC sees if the network is clear to send data
3. Send Data	MAC packs up the data and sends it out
4. Receive Data	The other device gets the data and checks if it’s okay
5. Show Content	If all is good, you see or hear your stream

MAC is a behind-the-scenes helper that keeps your streaming smooth and your data moving safely.

How We Compare Streaming Protocols

We look at several key points when comparing streaming protocols. This helps us figure out which one works best for different streaming needs:

Latency

Latency is how long it takes for data to go from the source to the viewer. It’s very important for live events and when people need to interact. Here’s how some protocols compare:

Protocol	Usual Latency
WebRTC	Less than 1 second
RTMP	2-5 seconds
HLS	6-30+ seconds
MPEG-DASH	6-30+ seconds

Scalability

This is about how many people can watch at the same time. We check:

• How many viewers it can handle
• What kind of setup it needs
• If it works with content delivery networks (CDNs)

Security

Keeping content safe is key. We look at:

• How it encrypts data (like AES 128/256-bit)
• If it supports digital rights management (DRM)
• How it checks who’s allowed to watch

Compatibility

It’s important that many devices can use the protocol. We check if it works on:

• Web browsers
• Phones and tablets
• Smart TVs and game consoles

Quality of Service (QoS)

This is about keeping the viewing experience good. We look at:

Feature	What It Does
Adaptive bitrate	Changes video quality based on internet speed
Error handling	Fixes problems when data gets lost
Buffer management	Keeps video smooth even when internet is slow

1. RTMP (Real-Time Messaging Protocol)

RTMP is a streaming protocol made by Adobe. It’s good for sending audio, video, and data quickly over the internet. Though it’s older, many people still use it because it works well for live streaming.

Latency

RTMP is fast:

Delay Time	Use Case
2-5 seconds	Good for live events and gaming

It keeps a steady connection between the sender and viewer, which helps keep delays short.

Scalability

RTMP can handle many viewers, but has some limits:

Feature	Details
Viewer Numbers	Can serve many, but needs good server setup
Setup Needs	Requires special RTMP servers or CDN help
CDN Use	Works well with CDNs to reach more viewers

Security

RTMP has basic safety features:

• Controls who can watch
• Allows simple content protection
• Can use encryption, but might need extra security

Compatibility

RTMP works with:

Device/Platform	Support
Web Browsers	Limited (due to Flash ending)
Encoders	Widely supported
Media Servers	Commonly used

It’s often used to start streams, which are then changed to newer formats for viewing.

Quality of Service (QoS)

RTMP has features to keep streams running smoothly:

• Can send multiple streams at once
• Changes video quality based on internet speed
• Uses TCP to make sure data arrives correctly

Even though it’s old, RTMP is still useful. It’s good for quick streaming and works with many encoders. But because new web browsers don’t support it well, it’s often used with newer methods to get videos to viewers.

2. HLS (HTTP Live Streaming)

HLS is a streaming method created by Apple. It sends video and audio over the internet using regular web technology. Many people use it because it works on lots of devices and gives a good viewing experience.

Latency

HLS can have more delay than RTMP:

Type	Delay
Regular HLS	10-30 seconds
Low-Latency HLS	2-5 seconds

The newer Low-Latency HLS tries to cut down this delay.

Scalability

HLS is good at reaching many viewers:

Feature	How it helps
Works with CDNs	Spreads content to more places
Changes quality	Fits different internet speeds
Uses normal web servers	Easy to set up and run

These things help HLS reach big audiences, even when internet connections vary.

Security

HLS keeps content safe:

• Uses strong AES-128 encryption
• Works with different content protection systems
• Can check who’s allowed to watch

Compatibility

HLS works on many devices:

Device	How well it works
iPhones and Macs	Built-in support
Android devices	Works on most
Web browsers	Widely supported
Smart TVs	Often supported

This wide support helps content makers reach more viewers.

Quality of Service (QoS)

HLS has features to make viewing better:

• Changes video quality based on internet speed
• Supports multiple languages and subtitles
• Lets viewers start where they left off
• Sends video in small parts to save internet data

These features help make HLS popular with both content providers and viewers.

3. MPEG-DASH (Dynamic Adaptive Streaming over HTTP)

MPEG-DASH is a standard for sending video over the internet. It’s used by many content providers because it works well for both them and viewers.

Latency

MPEG-DASH can be faster than some other streaming methods:

Protocol	How Long It Takes
MPEG-DASH	2-10 seconds
HLS	10-30 seconds

It sends video parts quickly, which helps reduce waiting time.

Scalability

MPEG-DASH can handle many viewers at once:

Feature	How It Helps
Uses simple servers	Can serve more people
Works with CDNs	Spreads content widely
Offers multiple stream options	Fits different internet speeds

These features help MPEG-DASH work well for big audiences.

Compatibility

MPEG-DASH works on many devices:

Device	How Well It Works
Smartphones	Very good
Tablets	Very good
Smart TVs	Very good
Computers	Very good
Apple devices (Safari)	Not as good (needs different browser)

It works on most devices, but Apple’s Safari needs a different app to play MPEG-DASH videos.

Quality of Service (QoS)

MPEG-DASH helps make watching videos smooth:

• Changes video quality based on internet speed
• Works with different types of video files
• Helps stop videos from stopping to load
• Makes playback smooth with less waiting

These features make MPEG-DASH popular for both people who share videos and those who watch them.

4. WebRTC (Web Real-Time Communication)

WebRTC is a protocol that lets web browsers talk to each other directly. It’s good for streaming because it’s fast and gives high-quality video.

Latency

WebRTC is much faster than other streaming methods:

Protocol	How Long It Takes
WebRTC	Less than half a second
RTMP	About 5 seconds
HLS	10-30 seconds

This speed makes WebRTC great for things like video calls, live sports, and online games.

Scalability

WebRTC works well for some uses but not others:

Use	How Well It Works
Small groups	Very good
Big audiences	Not as good
Direct connections	Works well
Server needs	Less than other methods

It’s best for small groups or when people need to talk back and forth quickly.

Compatibility

Most new web browsers can use WebRTC:

Browser	Can It Use WebRTC?
Google Chrome	Yes
Mozilla Firefox	Yes
Safari	Yes
Microsoft Edge	Yes
Internet Explorer	No

This means many devices can use WebRTC without needing extra software.

Quality of Service (QoS)

WebRTC has features that make streaming look and sound good:

Feature	What It Does
Adjusts video quality	Matches your internet speed
Uses good video formats	Makes video look clear
Fixes sound issues	Removes echoes and background noise
Changes how much data it sends	Keeps video playing smoothly

These features help WebRTC work well when you need fast, high-quality video and sound.

sbb-itb-738ac1e

5. SRT (Secure Reliable Transport)

SRT is an open-source protocol for sending video over the internet. It works well even when internet connections are not great.

Latency

SRT is fast at sending video:

Protocol	How Long It Takes
SRT	Less than 1 to 2 seconds
RTMP	About 5 seconds
HLS	10-30 seconds

SRT can fix lost data quickly and change how it sends video to keep quality good.

Security

SRT keeps video safe:

Security Feature	What It Does
Encryption	Hides video data from others
Stream ID	Checks who can watch
Firewall passing	Helps video get through firewalls

These features make SRT good for sending private videos over public internet.

Quality of Service (QoS)

SRT has ways to keep video looking good:

Feature	How It Helps
Fixes lost data	Keeps video smooth when internet is bad
Changes video quality	Matches internet speed
Fixes errors	Helps when some data is lost
Manages timing	Makes sure video plays smoothly

These help SRT send good video even when the internet is not working well.

Compatibility

SRT is still new, so not everything can use it yet:

Where It’s Used	How Well It Works
Video sending software	More programs are adding it
Content delivery networks	More are starting to use it
Web browsers	Not many can use it without extra software

SRT is free for anyone to use, so more places are starting to work with it.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Each streaming method has good and bad points. Here’s a simple look at what each one does well and not so well:

Method	Good Points	Bad Points
RTMP	Fast, works on many systems	Hard to use for many viewers, not very safe
HLS	Can handle many viewers, safe	Slower
MPEG-DASH	Changes quality based on internet, works for many viewers	Hard to set up
WebRTC	Very fast, good for talking	Not good for big groups
SRT	Safe, works well on bad internet	Uses more internet data

RTMP is quick but not great for big crowds or keeping things private. HLS can handle lots of people and is safe, but it’s slower. MPEG-DASH changes video quality to match your internet but can be tricky to use. WebRTC is best for small groups who need to talk fast. SRT keeps things safe and works even when the internet is bad, but it needs more data.

When picking a method, think about:

• How fast you need it to be
• How many people will watch
• How safe it needs to be
• What devices people will use

For talking back and forth quickly, WebRTC or RTMP might be best. For big shows where speed isn’t as important, HLS or MPEG-DASH could work better. If you need to keep things safe and the internet might be bad, SRT is a good choice.

New Developments in Streaming Protocols

Streaming technology keeps getting better. Here are some new ways to send videos over the internet:

Faster HLS and DASH

HLS and DASH now have quicker versions:

Protocol	Old Speed	New Speed
HLS	10-30 seconds	2 seconds
DASH	6-30 seconds	Less than 1 second

These changes make live videos more fun to watch because there’s less waiting.

WebRTC Gets Better

WebRTC, which lets web browsers talk to each other, is improving:

• WHIP: A new way to send WebRTC videos that’s easier for many tools to use
• Bigger crowds: People are working to make WebRTC work for more viewers at once

SRT Grows

SRT is good for sending videos when the internet isn’t great:

• More people are using it
• It keeps videos looking good even when the internet is slow

Smart Computers Help Streaming

Computers are getting smarter at helping videos look good:

• They can guess when the internet will be slow and change the video to match
• They look at what’s in the video to make it smaller without losing quality

These new ways of streaming help make videos start faster, look better, and work for more people.

Picking the Right Protocol for Your Needs

Choosing the best streaming protocol helps viewers watch your content easily. Here’s how to pick the right one:

Audience and Compatibility

Think about what devices your viewers use:

Protocol	Works Best On
HLS	Apple devices, many others
MPEG-DASH	Many different devices
WebRTC	Web browsers
RTMP	Older systems
SRT	Growing on many devices

If many people watch on iPhones or iPads, HLS is a good choice.

How Fast You Need It

Some protocols are faster than others:

Protocol	Speed
WebRTC	Very fast (less than 1 second)
SRT	Fast (1-2 seconds)
MPEG-DASH	Can be fast (about 1 second)
HLS	Can be slow, but new versions are faster

Pick WebRTC if you need the fastest speed.

Video Quality and Internet Problems

If you want good quality even when the internet is bad:

• SRT: Works well on poor internet
• MPEG-DASH: Can use different video types for better quality
• HLS: Changes quality based on internet speed

Keeping Content Safe

If you need to protect your videos:

Protocol	Safety Features
SRT	Strong protection, works through firewalls
HLS	Can lock videos, check who’s watching
MPEG-DASH	Works with systems that control who can watch

Cost

Think about how much you want to spend:

• HLS and MPEG-DASH: Often cheaper because they use normal web servers
• SRT: Free to use, might save money
• RTMP: Might cost more because it needs special servers

How Hard It Is to Set Up

If you don’t have many tech experts:

• HLS: Easier to set up and use
• MPEG-DASH: Can do more, but harder to set up
• WebRTC: Needs more tech knowledge, but good for live talking

Pick the protocol that fits your needs for viewers, speed, quality, safety, cost, and how easy it is to use.

What’s Next for Streaming Protocols

New streaming methods are coming soon. Here’s what to look out for:

WebRTC and SRT Becoming More Common

WebRTC and SRT are getting better for sending videos:

Protocol	What’s Good About It
WebRTC	Very fast, works in web browsers
SRT	Works well when internet is bad

More tools are starting to use these, which might replace older ways like RTMP.

WHIP Makes Things Easier

WHIP is a new way to use WebRTC:

• Makes it easier to use WebRTC with current video tools
• Helps people send videos from web browsers without extra equipment

Smart Computers Help Streaming

Computers are getting smarter at making videos look good:

• Change video quality based on internet speed
• Look at what’s in the video to make it smaller but still clear
• Guess when internet will be slow and get ready for it

Even Faster Video Sending

People want videos to start even quicker:

Protocol	How Fast It Might Be
WebRTC	Less than half a second
New HLS/DASH	About 1 second

This will help make live sports, games, and online events more fun to watch.

Making Things Work Together Better

People are trying to make all streaming methods work together:

• CMAF helps HLS and DASH work the same way
• More free-to-use methods are being made

This will make it easier for different devices to play videos.

As streaming gets better, we’ll see faster ways to send videos that look good and work on more devices.

Wrap-up

We’ve looked at different ways to control how videos are sent over the internet. Each method has its own good and bad points. Here’s a quick look at what we learned:

Method	What it’s good at	What it’s used for
RTMP	Fast, works on old systems	Sending videos to servers, old setups
HLS	Works on many devices, changes quality	Videos you can watch anytime, big live shows
MPEG-DASH	Works with many systems, changes quality	Sending videos to different devices
WebRTC	Very fast, works in web browsers	Video calls, live chats
SRT	Works well on bad internet	Sending videos to servers, replacing RTMP

New ways of sending videos, like WebRTC and SRT, are getting better. They fix problems that older methods had, making videos start faster and look better.

When picking a way to send videos, think about:

• How fast it needs to be
• How many people will watch
• What devices people will use
• How good the video needs to look
• How safe it needs to be

In the future, we’ll see more new ways to send videos. People are working on making videos start faster, look better, and use less internet data.

The best way to send videos depends on what you need. By knowing what each method does well, you can pick the right one for your videos and the people watching them.

FAQs

Which protocol is best for streaming?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The best protocol depends on what you need:

Protocol	Best For	Why
HLS & MPEG-DASH	High-quality streaming	Can change video quality based on internet speed
RTMP	Quick streaming	Good for sending videos to YouTube and other platforms
WebRTC	Very fast communication	Great for video calls with little delay

Pick based on whether you want high-quality video or fast streaming.

Should I use HLS or Dash?

HLS and MPEG-DASH are similar, but have some differences:

Feature	HLS	MPEG-DASH
Video types	Works with HEVC/H.265	Works with many video types
Device support	Works on more devices, especially Apple	Works on many devices
Speed	Can be fast	Can be fast
For developers	Less flexible	More flexible

Choose based on what devices your viewers use and what you need for your project.

Related posts

• Live Streaming Copyright Protection: 10 Tips for 2024
• Protect Your Content from Unauthorized Sharing
• Cloud Content Protection: Ultimate Guide 2024